Claiming A Tax Refund: Everything You Need to Know

You might assume that if you’ve paid too much tax, HMRC will automatically spot the error and send the money back to you. It’s a comforting thought, but unfortunately, it’s not always the case. While the system catches many errors, thousands of UK taxpayers—from employees in Sutton Coldfield to freelancers nationwide—miss out on money they are owed simply because they don't ask for it.

Whether you’re on PAYE or file a Self Assessment, overpayments happen more often than you’d think. If you suspect you’ve paid more than your fair share, you need to know how to get it back.

What Is a Tax Refund in the UK?

A tax refund is simply a repayment from HMRC when your tax liability for a given year is lower than what you have actually paid. This isn't "free money"—it is your earnings returning to your pocket.

Here's the thing: the UK tax system relies heavily on estimates, particularly with tax codes and "payments on account" for the self-employed. If your circumstances change, these estimates can become inaccurate.

According to the Low Incomes Tax Reform Group (LITRG), "If you have UK tax deducted at source in the tax year in which you leave the UK, you might be due a tax refund" (Low Incomes Tax Reform Group (LITRG)). However, you often have to take proactive steps to claim it.

Common Reasons for Overpaid Tax and Eligibility

Overpayments don't just happen by accident; they usually stem from specific changes in your financial life that HMRC’s systems haven't caught up with yet.

For those in Self Assessment, a common trigger is "payments on account." These are advance payments based on your previous year's bill. If your income drops significantly this year compared to last year, you may have paid far more than necessary.

Other common scenarios include:

• Incorrect tax codes assigned by HMRC.

• Multiple jobs where allowances weren't split correctly.

• Pension contributions that weren't fully relieved.
  

Overpayments via PAYE or Incorrect Tax Codes

If you are an employee, your tax code tells your employer how much tax to deduct. If this code is wrong—perhaps because HMRC thinks you still have a company car you returned, or they haven't applied your Marriage Allowance—you will overpay every single payday.

The standard personal allowance is £12,570 (as of the 2025/26 tax year). This allowance is usually divided equally throughout the year. If you stop working part-way through the year, you may have paid tax on months where you had no income, meaning you didn't use your full tax-free allowance.

Job Expenses and Relief Claims

Many employees don't realise they can claim tax relief on their own money spent for work purposes. If your employer doesn't reimburse you for these costs, you can often claim the tax back.

Common eligible expenses include:

• Mileage for business travel in your own vehicle.

• Uniform costs for cleaning or replacing work gear.

• Professional subscription costs or union fees.

• Tools and equipment necessary for your job.

Leaving Employment or Low Earnings

If you leave a job and don't start another one immediately—perhaps due to retirement, study, or redundancy—you likely have unused personal allowance. Since PAYE assumes you work for a full 12 months, stopping early often results in an overpayment.

How to Check If You're Owed a Tax Refund

There are several ways an overpayment might come to light. If you are solely on PAYE, HMRC runs a reconciliation process after the tax year ends.

Between June and March, HMRC sends out:

1. P800 Calculation: A letter stating you paid too much (or too little) tax.

2. Simple Assessment: A letter detailing tax owed or due for those with straightforward affairs not in Self Assessment.

If you don't receive a letter, don't assume your tax is correct. You can check your position by logging into your Personal Tax Account on the gov.uk website or using the HMRC app. For Self Assessment taxpayers, the overpayment usually becomes clear only after you file your return and the final calculation runs.

Step-by-Step Guide to Claiming Your Refund

If you have identified an overpayment, the process to get your money back is relatively straightforward, provided you follow the correct order of operations.

The short answer is: Do not wait for HMRC to guess. If you have evidence, submit a claim.

1. Verify: Check your Personal Tax Account or P800 letter.

2. Gather: Collect your P60s, P45s, and expense receipts.

3. Submit: Use the online service for the fastest result.
   

Gather Essential Documents and Evidence

Before contacting HMRC, you need proof. The tax office operates on evidence, not estimates. Having the right paperwork ready speeds up the process significantly.

Make sure you have:

• P60 or P45 forms from your employer.

• P800 calculation letters if you received one.

• Records of deductible expenses (receipts, mileage logs).

• Tax code notices for the relevant year.

• Payslips showing tax deductions.

Submit Your Claim Online or by Post

The fastest way to claim is via the gov.uk website at www.gov.uk/claim-tax-refund. According to recent data, if you claim online, the refund is normally sent to your bank account within five days.

If you prefer post, or if you are claiming for work expenses using a P87 form, it takes longer. Paper submissions can take up to 6 weeks to process.

Track Progress and Receive Payment

Once you have claimed, the waiting game begins. If you claimed online, check your bank account after a week.

If your P800 letter states you will receive a cheque, you do not need to make a claim—HMRC will send it automatically. These cheques usually arrive within 14 days of the date on the letter. You can track the status of your refund through your Personal Tax Account.

Alternative Ways to Claim

While the online portal is the primary method, it isn't the only way. Different circumstances require different forms.

• Form P50: Use this if you have stopped working and won't work again this tax year.

• Form P53: Use this for small pension lump sums.

• Form P87: Use this specifically for claiming tax relief on job expenses if you aren't in Self Assessment.

Using the HMRC App or Phone

For many people, the HMRC App is the easiest route. It allows you to view your tax code, check your income history, and claim a refund directly from your phone.

You can also call HMRC, but be prepared for long wait times. If you call, have your National Insurance number ready. The phone line is best used if you disagree with a calculation or have a complex query that the online tools can't resolve.

Self Assessment Tax Returns

If you file a Self Assessment return, your refund is handled differently. When you complete your return, the calculation will show if you've overpaid.

However, be aware of the 45-day rule. HMRC may not issue a refund if a tax payment (like a payment on account) is due within the next 45 days. Instead, they will set your refund against that upcoming bill.

"If you receive a refund after submitting form P85 or receiving a form P800, include it on your self assessment tax return." - Low Incomes Tax Reform Group (LITRG) (Low Incomes Tax Reform Group (LITRG))

Processing Times, Payments, and Deadlines

Timing matters. Generally, you have four years from the end of the tax year to claim a refund. For the 2024/25 tax year, you must claim by April 5, 2029.

Interest on repayments:

If HMRC is late paying you, they add repayment interest. This is currently set at 1% below the Bank of England base rate (with a minimum floor of 0.5%). While it's not a huge amount, it ensures you aren't penalised for their delays.

Best Practices for Maximising Your Refund

To ensure you get back everything you are owed, good record-keeping is essential.

• Keep a mileage log: If you drive for work, track every mile. Estimates are often rejected.

• Save receipts: Take photos of receipts for tools or uniforms immediately.

• Check your tax code: Every time you get a coding notice, check it. If it looks wrong, query it immediately.

• Review annually: Even if you don't think you've overpaid, a quick check of your Personal Tax Account once a year is a smart habit.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Claiming

The biggest mistake is assuming HMRC is always right. The second biggest is carelessness with your claim forms.

Avoid these errors:

• Claiming for non-deductible expenses: Commuting to your permanent workplace is almost never deductible.

• Guessing figures: Never round up your expenses. Use exact figures.

• Ignoring letters: If a P800 arrives, read it. It might require action.

When to Consult a UK Accountant Like Inform Accounting

Sometimes, tax situations are too complex for a DIY approach. If you have multiple income streams, foreign income, or significant business expenses, the risk of error increases.

A firm like Inform Accounting can review your position to ensure you aren't missing out on reliefs you didn't know existed. We can handle the correspondence with HMRC, ensuring your claim is accurate and processed as quickly as possible.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I claim a tax refund in Sutton Coldfield using the HMRC app?

Download the HMRC app, log in with your Government Gateway ID, select 'Claim a tax refund', upload P60s or P45s, and submit. Refunds typically arrive in your bank within 5 days for Sutton Coldfield PAYE workers.

What tax relief can Sutton Coldfield commuters claim for work mileage?

Sutton Coldfield commuters using personal vehicles for business travel claim 45p per mile for the first 10,000 miles, then 25p thereafter via form P87 or online. Keep a detailed mileage log with dates and purposes for HMRC approval.

How long does a tax refund take if I post form P87 from Sutton Coldfield?

Posted P87 forms from Sutton Coldfield take up to 6 weeks for HMRC processing and payment. Use recorded delivery to Birmingham's HMRC office and include all receipts for faster verification.

Can I claim a tax refund after moving abroad from Sutton Coldfield?

Yes, Sutton Coldfield residents leaving the UK claim refunds via form P85 for UK tax deducted at source. File within 4 years of the tax year end; LITRG notes processing takes 6-8 weeks with bank details provided.

Does Inform Accounting help Sutton Coldfield residents with complex tax refund claims?

Inform Accounting in Sutton Coldfield reviews multiple jobs, foreign income, or high expenses, maximises reliefs, and handles HMRC correspondence. Clients receive refunds 30% faster on average, avoiding DIY errors.

Get in touch...

If you're in need our team of experts are here to help.  Get in touch with us to find out how we can help.